The Importance of Reputation in Public Contract Bids

The Importance of Reputation in Public Contract Bids


Public procurement is valued as an important part of the European economy, accounting for 15% of its GDP. The directive 2014/24/EU introduced the possibility of using past performance information to limit bidders’ participation. It also states that public contracts can be awarded on the basis of many factors, not only price. The directive has opened the door to the introduction of reputational incentives in order to improve supplier performance.
In the working paper Past Performance and Procurement Outcomes, Francesco Decarolis, Riccardo Pacini and Giancarlo Spagnolo studied the outcome of an experiment run by a large multi-utility firm in Central Italy. The introduction of a reputation mechanism for suppliers who maintain the power grid had a significant impact on their performance.
“Over the course of a year, after the announcement of the switch from price-only to price-and-rating auctions, with a scoring rule assigning 25 percent to the reputation index, overall compliance improved from 25% to 80%”, professor Decarolis says. Prices lowered right after the announcement when suppliers competed to win contracts to get scored.
After having established a good reputation, though, the price increased by 9%. “According to our cost-benefit analysis, the price increase appears rather small when compared to the improvement in performance”. Yet the EU regards reputational incentives with suspicion, whereas in the US past performance has played a role in public procurement since the mid-1990s. “European lawmakers fear favoritism and corruption. Mostly important, they think that these mechanisms may prevent the creation of a single market, by favoring already established local suppliers”.

Read more about this topic:
Gianmarco Ottaviano. The Cost of Non-Europe
Electoral Results Explained Through Emotion Theory
The Four Pillars of European Capitalism
Human Rights Are Increasingly Important
Transparency Means Banks Won’t Need to Be Saved
The Robot Vote Has Brought Success for Nationalists
Finding a Compromise for Tomorrow’s Relations Between UE and UK
Foreign CEOs Get More out of Acquisitions
When It Comes to Fake News, Don’t Imitate the USA
A Common Identity Could Derive from the Protection of Civil Rights
Productivity Cannot Be Balanced with Computers
Europe Should Opt for Qualified Majority Voting on Taxation Issues
My Europe: Seven Bocconi alumni who work for various EU institutions tell us what Europe means to them

by Claudio Todesco


All News
  • Economics Research, Bocconi in the European Top 5

    In the Tilburg University ranking of the best universities for scientific performance in economics research, Bocconi is 4th in Europe, 1st in continental Europe, and 18th in the world  

  • Lockdown Measures Are Not the Only Things Keeping Us at Home

    Two Bocconi MSc students, in a team with two Oxford PhD students, had their paper published in two prestigious outlets. Observing mobility data from mobile devices, they found that people in the US often distanced themselves before official measures were imposed in counties with high education, high trust in science and high income  


  May 2020  
Mon Tue Wed Thu Fri Sat Sun
        1 2 3
4 5 6 7 8 9 10
11 12 13 14 15 16 17
18 19 20 21 22 23 24
25 26 27 28 29 30 31


All Seminars
  • Imperfect Macroeconomic Expectations: Evidence and Theory

    Marios Angeletos (MIT) Paper


  • The Commission's proposals for the Multiannual Financial Framework and the Recovery Instrument
    The EU Response to the Covid Crisis

    Chair Eleanor Spaventa, Bocconi University Speakers Mario Monti, President, Bocconi University; Catherine De Vries, Bocconi University; Guido Tabellini, Bocconi University To register, please contact