Streamlining Fundamental Models
ACCOUNTING |

Streamlining Fundamental Models

STEPHEN PENMAN RECASTS THE CONSUMPTION BASED PRICE MODEL FROM AN ACCOUNTING OUTCOME PERSPECTIVE

When a scholar is also one of the most indisputable experts of a field, he or she reaches a stage in which challenging theories that shaped the literature becomes approachable. This is what Stephen Penman, Distinguished Professor at Bocconi Department of Accounting, does in his most recent publication in the Journal of Accounting and Economics. Specifically, the article aims to recast the well-known consumption-based price model but from an accounting outcome perspective.
 
The consumption-based price model is part of wide stream of literature which crosses several fields and has its roots in the capital asset pricing model (also known with the acronym CAPM). CAPM describes the relationship between the risk embedded in the market and the expected return of assets. The result of this model is represented by a factor – also known as beta – that tells how much risk an investor is adding to his or her portfolio by investing in that specific stock. The higher the added risk, the higher the return an investor expects (requires) from an asset.
 
When the beta employed represents not the systemic risk, but the added uncertainty in consumption growth that would come to an investor from holding the asset, we have the consumption-based model. The higher the added uncertainty in consumption growth, the higher the return an investor expects (requires) from an asset.
 
Link to related stories. Image: a hand holding money and an arrow pointing up. Story headline: Short Term Debt Comes with a Penalty in the Cost of Equity Link to related stories. Image: professor Stephen Penman. Story headline: Telling the Good and the Bad in Accounting  Link to related stories. Image: a bridge under construction. Story headline: A New Model Says If an Infrastructure Asset Price Is Right  

Even if many scholars have attempted to provide new empirical evidence to the model, Professor Penman, together with his co-author Julie Zhu (Fudan University), brings to the table of asset pricing literature a model that uses accounting principles as bridge between consumption and key accounting variables.
 
The two accounting relations adopted by Penman are the “clean-surplus” and the “realization principle for booking earnings”. While the first has the objective of explaining the existing relationship between asset book value, earnings, and dividends, the second explicates that earnings are booked only when the risk is resolved.
 
The key novelties presented by the model are the presence of a single factor and its interpretability. As a matter of fact, the model is defined by its authors as “parsimonious” because it captures most of the returns by adopting one single factor. This represents a point of distance from those models that use a “zoo of factors”.
Moreover, the factor is transparent because its interpretation is straight forward. This is easily traceable back to the philosophy of Professor Penman of working with concrete tools.
 
Interestingly, thanks to their new research, Penman and Zhu brought to light that accounting numbers have their relevance. Indeed, they are able to tell their own story and should not be ignored by scholars as well as practitioners because they convey useful information about risk and expected returns.
 
Penman, S., & Zhu, J. (2022). “An accounting-based asset pricing model and a fundamental factor.” Journal of Accounting and Economics, 101476. DOI: https://doi.org/10.1016/j.jacceco.2021.101476.

by Giulia Sargiacomo
Bocconi Knowledge newsletter

News

  • Four Threats to European Banks in 2023

    Andrea Resti describes the various occurrences that may impair Euro area lenders' sustainability in the near future  

  • Monitor for Circular Fashion Launches Eight Pilot Tests

    In the 2022 report of the observatory by SDA Bocconi School of Management and powered by Enel X, the analysis of sustainability indicators in the textile sector is applied to eight innovative prototypes made by partner companies. From organic cotton jeans to a tshirt that can be repaired, a bag that can be recycled, and a shoe that can be sewn at home  

Seminars

  December 2022  
Mon Tue Wed Thu Fri Sat Sun
      1 2 3 4
5 6 7 8 9 10 11
12 13 14 15 16 17 18
19 20 21 22 23 24 25
26 27 28 29 30 31  

Seminars