Wonderful Building, Woeful Planning in Edinburgh

Wonderful Building, Woeful Planning in Edinburgh


The Scottish Parliament building in Holyrood, Edinburgh, has won nine major international architectural awards. It is considered to be a masterful piece of architecture, but also a dismal economic failure. It was expected to open in 2000, it did in 2004. Its costs increased from a budget of £40 million to a final cost of £431 million. “Everything that could have gone wrong, went wrong”, Beatrice Manzoni says. Along with Leonardo Caporarello, she uses the Holyrood story both as a case study in SDA and Bocconi classes and as an online management simulation designed by the SDA Bocconi Learning Lab.
“The client started off on the wrong foot”, she says. “He asked for a sensational project that was also cheap and delivered quickly – it was an unrealistic goal. The architectural competition was held with no shared evaluation system. There was no real project execution plan and risk assessment policy. Also, the tendering and construction procedures were not compatible with a reasonable timetable”. Team dynamics caused further trouble. Four different project managers were appointed. The starchitect demanded to participate in the decision-making process, but failed to attend meetings. Cultural differences among team members, who were partly Scottish and partly Spanish, created tensions. As if that was not enough, both the architect Enric Miralles and the political project leader, Prime Minister Donald Dewar, died in the year 2000.
“This is a textbook case of bad project and team management. When managing a complex multi-actor project, it is essential to oversee both its ‘hard’ and ‘soft’ components. It is fundamental to establish a clear timetable, costs and objectives, design an effective decision-making process, plan every step and review risks. It is also important to appoint a project manager with both technical skills and relational abilities. Architects who want the spotlight should be carefully managed. When it comes to complex projects, the genius is collective”.

Read more about this topic:
Tracking the Arrow of Time to Understand the Present. By Guido Alfani
Giuseppe Berta. From Henry Ford to Steve Jobs: The (French) Evolution of Entrepreneurship
Maristella Botticini. Culture and Demographics: What We Can Learn from Jewish History
Andrea Colli. How, When and Why the Benetton Family Became Edizione Ltd
Manuela Geranio. Modern Public Limited Companies? They Started in Rome
Elisabetta Merlo. Corporate Heritage: A Competitive Advantage for Companies
Mara Squicciarini. How Important Are School Curricula for a Country’s Development? Very
Guido Tabellini. From Florence to San Francisco: Good Institutions Attract Creative People
Tamas Vonyo. The Myth of the Marshall Plan and Its Effects on Growth
The Ricordi Archives and the Value of Memory. Interview with Pierluigi Ledda

by Claudio Todesco


All News
  • Emotions Power Public Administration

    Research by Turrini, Cristofoli, and Valotti finds a shared feature in the realization of COVID hospitals in Milan, New York, and Wuhan  

  • Fiscal Expansion: Spend as if You Have to Pay It Back

    Bocconi students on the seminars organized by IGIER. In the latest article of the series, Sviatoslav Tiupin reports on the work of Olivier Blanchard and John Cochrane  


  August 2020  
Mon Tue Wed Thu Fri Sat Sun
          1 2
3 4 5 6 7 8 9
10 11 12 13 14 15 16
17 18 19 20 21 22 23
24 25 26 27 28 29 30


All Seminars
  • The Department of Finance will be interviewing and holding seminars with selected candidates on the following dates:   January 12th January 14th January 15th January 18th January 22nd January 25th January 27th February 1st February 3rd   Selected candidates will be contacted individually via e-mail. If you would like to follow the candidate's seminar you can contact the department administration office at dip.fin@unibocconi.it

  • Flexible Wages, Bargaining, and the Gender Gap

    Barbara Biasi (Yale)